Create a Guide/Template: Giving qualitative feedback on design

[daniellex0]

Overview

We need to create a guide for giving qualitative feedback on designs, so that volunteers at Hack for LA can learn effective practices in design critiques.

Action Items

The phases in the guide-making process are listed below. Each phase displayed in blue is linked to a wiki page with instructions on how to complete that phase. Open the wiki page in a new tab, copy the instructions for each part into the section labeled 'Tasks' at the bottom of this issue, and complete each task listed.

• Gather Examples Solo (open in a new tab)
• Gather Examples Collaboratively
• Create a Guide Draft
  • If needed, create a template
• Have your guide peer reviewed
• Present your guide for leadership review

Resources/Instructions

Google Drive Folder for this Guide’s documents and shortcuts (to documents in other locations)
0132 Giving qualitative feedback on design

Guide:

• UX/UI Designers: Give Qualitative Feedback

Projects to Check

Tasks

• This is where you will copy instructions from the wiki page for the step you are currently on.

[daniellex0]

Examples of what can be included in this guide:

• Code of Conduct
• actionable feedback
  • design aspect
  • glossary/heuristic
  • check list
• examples

[anonymousanemone]

For devs adding this guide to the Toolkit page: the guide card Illustration and image credit information is in the Toolkit page Figma file (blue rectangle on bottom left)

[ExperimentsInHonesty]

After the leadership review this should go into the prioritized backlog

[Aparna1Gopal]

As per Instructions moving this to prioritized Backlog

[JesseTheCleric]

Prior version of issue

Overview

We need to create a guide for giving qualitative feedback on designs, so that volunteers at Hack for LA can learn effective practices in design critiques.

Action Items

• Research existing information about providing design feedback in relevant resources, online articles, etc.
  • Once done, remove the "Guide: Research" label and add the "Guide: Gather Examples" label
• Gather examples and practices of other projects or volunteers regarding providing design feedback (if you can find)
  • Once done, remove the "Guide: Gather Examples" label and add the "Guide: Draft Guide" label
• Create a draft guide, either in markdown format in this issue or a google doc in the [ux/ui google drive]
  • Once done, remove the "Guide: Draft Guide" label and add the "Guide: Review Guide" label
• Review the guide with UX/UI community of practice
  • Once done, remove the "Guide: Review Guide" label and add the "Guide: Leadership Review" label
• Present to the Hack for LA leadership team for sign off
  • Once approved, remove the "Guide: Leadership Review" label and add the "Guide: Place Guide" label

Resources

Update issue #97 with the name of item you are working on

Draft Guide

[JesseTheCleric]

Assignee, Labels, Project Board Placement, and Milestones for this issue in the UI/UX Repo:

[JesseTheCleric]

Files in this Issue

UX/UI DESIGNERS: HOW TO GIVE QUALITATIVE FEEDBACK

• This file will need to be moved to the knowledgebase-content Google Drive