handNote in allen Dokumenten: an der falschen Stelle und nicht ideal umgesetzt

[cthomasdta]

Anlässlich einer Frage von Syd Bauman, vgl. Mail

Am 04.12.2024 um 16:36 schrieb Christian Thomas (BBAW):

here's an example of a //handNote encoding, with different scribes and writing devices:

<handDesc>
   <handNote xml:id="major_hand" scope="major" medium="brown_ink" scribe="author" scribeRef="#KL">Hand des Nachschreibers Karol Libelt, braune Tinte, vorwiegend in Kurrentschrift.</handNote>
   <handNote xml:id="pencil" scope="minor" medium="pencil" scribe="annotator">Eine Anmerkung, Bleistift, unbekannter Verfasser.</handNote>
   <handNote xml:id="pencil2" scope="minor" medium="pencil" scribe="archivist">Schreiber des Titelblattes <persName resp="#BF" ref=["http://d-nb.info/gnd/117640387"](http://d-nb.info/gnd/117640387)><forename>Józef</forename> <surname>Łepkowski</surname></persName>, Bleistift.</handNote>
   <handNote xml:id="pencil3" scope="minor" medium="pencil" scribe="archivist2" scribeRef="#BJK">Anmerkung auf dem Titelblatt, Bleistift, von <persName resp="#BF" ref=["http://d-nb.info/gnd/172194571"](http://d-nb.info/gnd/172194571)><forename>Józef</forename> <surname>Korzeniowski</surname></persName>.</handNote>
</handDesc>

This is taken from my edition of https://www.deutschestextarchiv.de/libelt_hs6623ii_1828 in the German Text Archive, cf. the header here https://www.deutschestextarchiv.de/api/tei_header/libelt_hs6623ii_1828.

It was encoded in 2016, and I would certainly do things differently now. […] I think there are some mistakes, above all, that

• we put the <handNote> elements inside /TEI/teiHeader[1]/fileDesc[1]/sourceDesc[1]/msDesc[1]/physDesc[1]/handDesc[1] and not in //profileDesc/handNotes/handNote. So I think at the moment it is simply in the wrong place,

• and the missing <handNotes> element to wrap around the single <handNote> elements is another, though slightly smaller mistake.

• ... and the @scribeRef values should point to an @xml:id elsewhere in the header, which it does for "#BJK" (= /TEI/teiHeader[1]/fileDesc[1]/titleStmt[1]/respStmt[6]/orgName[1]), but not for "#KL", which should point to an @xml:id in /TEI/teiHeader[1]/fileDesc[1]/titleStmt[1]/author[1]/persName[1] but that @xml:id is missing there...

At least the <handNote> elements themselves and their content are ok. But I should really improve the rest, right?